All musings

Wear themoustache

Someone drew on a mayoral candidate’s election signs in Ontario, so she drew the same on herself and filmed it. The clip went around the world. It is a near perfect lesson in what to do when your brand gets mocked, and when not to try it.

Somebody always brings a marker.
No. 23 A six-minute read Filed under: Voice & reputation

Burlington is a city of close to two hundred thousand people on Lake Ontario, between Toronto and Hamilton. Ontario’s councils go to the polls on 26 October, and one of the people running for mayor is Lisa Kearns, who has spent the last eight years on the city’s council.

Over the Thanksgiving long weekend, a couple of her campaign signs were drawn on. On one, someone had blacked out her front teeth. On the other, they had given her a unibrow and a moustache.

Most candidates would post a photo of the damage, say something about respect and leave it there. Kearns made a short video instead. It opens on the sign with the missing teeth, then the camera moves across to Kearns standing beside it, with her own front teeth blacked out to match. Then it does the same with the other sign: unibrow, moustache, and there she is next to it, wearing both. The clip ends by pointing people to a guide on how to vote online.

Within days it had passed twenty-one thousand likes on Instagram, which is a lot for a council race in a mid-sized city. The Hamilton Spectator picked it up, and this week CNN and American local news did too. I first heard about it on Sunrise on Channel 7, here in Australia, which tells you how far a moustache can travel.

We are not taking a side in Burlington, and by the time you read this the city may have voted. The result does not change the point. Drawing on someone’s sign is still vandalism, and Ontario police reminded voters this season that it can be a criminal offence. What interests us is the response, because it is a near perfect example of something brands get wrong all the time.

Nobody shares a statement about respect

When someone takes a swing at a brand, the instinct is to defend it. The logo has been mocked, the ad parodied, the sign drawn on, so you correct the record and ask people to be better. It is a reasonable instinct, and it almost never travels.

Kearns did the opposite. She accepted the vandal’s version of her and put it on her own face. It is very hard to keep mocking someone who is already laughing with you. The joke stopped belonging to the person who drew it and started belonging to her.

Self-deprecation is a luxury of the competent.

It only works if you have earned it

There is some psychology under this. In 1966 Elliot Aronson and his colleagues ran the study now known as the pratfall effect. People listened to a recording of a quiz contestant who answered almost every question correctly and then, in some versions, spilled a cup of coffee. The contestant who spilled the coffee was rated as more likeable than the one who did not.

The caveat is the part most people skip. When an average contestant spilled the coffee, it made him less likeable, not more. The pratfall only helps if people already believe you are good at the job.

Kearns could afford the moustache because she had a record to stand on: last time she was re-elected to council with more than seventy per cent of the vote in her ward. Self-deprecation is a luxury of the competent. If people already doubt you, laughing at yourself just confirms it.

A joke with a job

She got something else right, and it is easy to miss. The video did not end on the laugh. It ended on how to vote.

Why she did it

We just did what felt natural and added some levity and … some humanity at a time when we were seeing low voter turnout.

— Lisa Kearns, to The Hamilton Spectator

That is not a small problem. In Burlington’s last council election, barely more than a quarter of eligible voters cast a ballot. A candidate’s real competitor is often the couch, and a video that makes people smile and then tells them how to vote from it is doing the actual work of the campaign.

I learned that in seven years of making political campaigns in New York. There is one result, on one date, and no partial credit. Nobody frames a clever ad for a candidate who lost.

So an ad that entertains without moving anyone is not a lesser success. It is money spent on applause. The funny ones that worked were always the ones where the laugh was carrying something.

Brands have been here before

In February 2018, KFC in the UK ran out of chicken. A change of delivery company left hundreds of its restaurants shut. Instead of a careful corporate apology, the agency Mother ran a full-page ad in the Sun and the Metro: an empty bucket with the letters rearranged to spell FCK, and underneath, “A chicken restaurant without any chicken. It’s not ideal.” It won gold at Cannes, and people still bring it up.

Same move. Name the embarrassing thing yourself, in your own voice, before everyone else finishes naming it for you.

Know a joke from a threat

This only works for one kind of attack. That same Thanksgiving weekend, in North Cowichan on Vancouver Island, a run of election signs were slashed, with the damage around the candidates’ faces and necks. Nobody there treated it as a joke. They reported it to the police, and then several candidates who were running against each other got together with volunteers and repaired one another’s signs. That was a good response too, just a different one.

The skill is reading which kind of moment you are in. A moustache is an invitation. A blade is a threat. Treating a threat like a joke makes you look careless, and treating a joke like a threat makes you look precious.

For a business that is not running for mayor

Your brand will be mocked at some point. Someone will parody your ad, rewrite your slogan or leave a review that is funnier than your marketing.

Decide how you behave before it happens. Work out who can say yes to a playful reply, because the window is days, not weeks, and a joke that waits on a committee arrives after everyone has moved on.

Check that you have earned it. If your service is genuinely letting people down, laughing along will read as not caring.

Give the joke a job. Point it at the thing you actually need people to do, whether that is booking, buying or turning up to vote.

Most brands spend their energy protecting the sign. The lesson from Burlington is that the sign was never the brand. The person standing next to it was.

When someone draws on your brand, and they will, sometimes the strongest thing you can do is wear the moustache.

Watch: Shallow DeepDive #21, the episode this musing sits alongside. Plays from YouTube when you hit play.

Offbrand is the Qualls journal: industry musings on messy briefs, useful brands and the work in between.

Start here

Ready for the day
someone draws on yours?

Put us to work