Same eye,different vision
The CBS Eye first went to air in 1951 and has barely changed since. Not long after it launched, its designer wanted to replace it. What CBS, NBC, America’s ABC and our own Seven teach about keeping, redrawing and replacing a mark.
On Saturday 20 October 1951, CBS Television started showing a new symbol in its station breaks: a circle, an almond shape inside it and a pupil in the middle. It was made under William Golden, the network’s art director, and the story goes that he took the idea from the hex signs painted on barns in Pennsylvania Dutch country, there to ward off evil spirits.
It worked in black and white, which mattered, because that is what television was. Seventy-five years later, through colour, high definition, streaming and several changes of owner, it is still essentially the same shape.
There is an Australian connection, too. CBS bought Network 10 out of administration in 2017, and on 6 October Paramount closed its takeover of Warner Bros. Discovery and renamed the whole company Skydance. The Eye and the 10 on your remote now sit in the same family. An American logo’s birthday is closer to home than it looks.
The designer got bored first
The best part of the Eye’s story came not long after it launched. Golden reportedly started work on a replacement. CBS’s president, Frank Stanton, stopped him.
Just when you’re beginning to be bored with what you’ve done is when it’s beginning to be noticed by your audience.
That is true of almost every brand we work with. The people inside a business see their logo hundreds of times a week. They are tired of it long before their customers have properly learned it. A new marketing manager arrives, the logo feels dated, and a rebrand begins to cure a fatigue that only exists inside the building.
The tempting conclusion is that everyone should leave their logos alone. That would make for a short article. It would also be poor advice, because CBS has not left its logo alone. It has kept the shape and kept working on everything around it.
Keeping a mark is not standing still
In 2020 the New York agency Gretel took on the whole CBS identity. The problem was not the Eye. News, sport, entertainment and the studio had each drifted into their own habits, with their own type, their own colours and even their own ways of using the Eye.
Gretel broke the mark into the shapes it is built from, the circles and the almond, and used them as building blocks for everything else. On screen, the Eye bursts outward and collapses back into itself. A new typeface replaced the condensed lettering, and the sound studio Antfood wrote a five-note signature that echoes the old spoken line, “This is CBS.”
Judged as a before and after of the logo, that project looks as though almost nothing changed. In fact nearly everything did, except the one thing people already knew.
Recognition does not live in the artwork. It lives in the audience.
NBC took the scenic route
The peacock arrived in 1956 to announce programs in colour, which also helped sell colour sets made by NBC’s owner, RCA. It was a promotion, not the network’s official logo. Over the next twenty years NBC tried a stacked monogram and then, on 1 January 1976, a bold new letter N.
That N was not cheap, and within weeks NBC learned that a public broadcaster in Nebraska had been using almost the same letter since the previous year. NBC settled by handing over new broadcasting equipment and paying for Nebraska’s next logo. That is the quiet risk of starting again: the cleaner and simpler the new mark, the more likely someone has already drawn it.
Meanwhile, research inside NBC in 1977 found the peacock still identified the network for viewers, even though it had been retired. In 1979 the bird came back, sitting inside the N, and in 1986 the designer Steff Geissbühler drew the peacock most of us know, reduced from eleven feathers to six.
The asset audiences valued was not the official one. NBC’s designers had the sense to notice, and the nerve to change it a great deal on the way back in.
ABC redrew the familiar
In 1962 Paul Rand gave America’s ABC three lowercase letters in a circle, flat and simple, made for an age before computers. Over the following decades it picked up every fashion television branding went through. When the network refreshed it in 2021, the trade press listed what was coming off: gradients, gel, glass, glow and bevel.
Trollbäck+Company redrew Rand’s mark properly, in versions that hold up from a phone icon to a billboard, and built a new system of type, motion and colour around it, with a new sound cue from YouTooCanWoo. The idea was right all along. The execution needed care.
We did a small version of this ourselves. When we took on Taguchi, the Melbourne marketing technology company, its symbol was a ring of orange dots with extra grey dots worked in among them. The idea was good. The extra bits were getting in its way. So we took them out, made the ring clearer and left the typeface beside it alone.
The mark Taguchi uses today is very close to that version. Nobody had to learn a new symbol. They just saw the old one more clearly.
Seven kept the memory and changed the drawing
In 1975, when Australia switched to colour, Seven wrapped its number in colour. On 1 January 2000, ahead of the Sydney Olympics, it launched a new mark by Cato, the Melbourne design firm.
Cato’s explanation is simple. The numeral and the colour bar were already part of Seven’s history, so they folded the colour bar into the seven itself. It was a completely new drawing, and it still felt like Seven, because the memory came along with it.
I understood that properly when I moved to Australia in 2018. The logos on the television meant nothing to me. Seven was a red shape. Everyone around me saw decades in it, years of the news, the cricket and the Olympics. I saw a seven.
That is when Stanton’s line made sense to me. Recognition does not live in the artwork. It lives in the audience, and it takes them years to build. When you throw a logo away, that is what goes with it.
Sometimes the mark should go
None of this means a logo should never be replaced. Some should. If the mark tells people something untrue about the business, ties it to a past it has genuinely left, or cannot do the work the business now needs, keeping it out of respect is nostalgia with a budget.
The point is that the size of the visual change should follow the business, not the boredom of the people who look at it every day.
For a business that is not a television network
Ask before you draw. Find out what people already recognise you by, and ask them rather than yourselves, because the people inside are the least reliable judges in the room.
Keep it if it is working. If the mark carries real recognition and has room for where you are going, put the effort into the system around it, the way CBS did.
Redraw it if the idea is sound. A tired drawing of a good idea needs craft, not a new idea.
Replace it if it is working against you, and make sure the new one is distinctive enough that nobody in Nebraska already owns it.
Whichever it is, the logo is the smallest part of the job. The bigger part is the type, the colour, the motion, the sound and the rules that let a busy team use it well on a deadline.
Seventy-five years of the Eye is an impressive piece of continuity, and Gretel’s work shows how much invention that continuity can hold. Stanton’s line is still the best test we know before anyone touches a logo.
Check who is bored. If it is you, that is not a brief.


Words: